How does Kant’s categorical imperative apply to the case of the lying promise? {{courseNav.course.topics.length}} chapters | Not sure what college you want to attend yet? You should first explain the Categorical Imperative itself, focusing on the particular formula you are considering, and then carefully show how that principle leads to a particular conclusion. ( Log Out /  Check if you have access via personal or institutional login, Interpretation and Misinterpretation of the Categorical Imperative, Kant’s Examples of the Categorical Imperative, Kant, Authority and the French Revolution, A Kantian conception of human flourishing, New Essays on Kantian Ethics and Virtue Ethics, Necessitation and Justification in Kant’s Ethics, Kant's Ethical Duties and their Feminist Implications, Canadian Journal of Philosophy Supplementary Volume, Kant's conception of virtue and the autocracy of pure practical reason, Individual and Collective Flourishing in Kant's Philosophy. A hypothetical categorical imperative provides a rule you need to follow to achieve a particular end. The requirements for the discussion this week include the following: The total combined word count for all of your posts, counted together, should be at least 600 words, not including references. To use the Formula of Universal Law as a test of the moral status of acts is often held to commit one to rigourism – to the view that all moral principles must be very general. From a more general perspective, if there were no abortions at all, on a finite planet we would see far too many people and so humanity would be doomed (“the Malthus argument”). Doing things based on emotion isn’t moral; the actions you take based on good will and rationality is what makes things moral. So with that in mind, if you do something based on a feeling of sympathy it isn’t necessarily moral because you did it. For example, most people consider owning personal property a positive thing. APPROVEDSCHOLARS – PLACE YOUR ORDER HERE:, The Paper is Written from Scratch Specifically for You. Comprehensive Assessment essay portion Essay, Quantitative Research Critique and Ethical Considerations (Research Paper Sample), Confidentiality & Authenticity Guaranteed, APPROVEDSCHOLARS Guarantee Timely Delivery of All Papers, Papers Written from Scratch and to Your Instructions, APPROVEDSCHOLARS Allow Direct Contact With Your Writer, Using APPROVEDSCHOLARS.COM Means Keeping Your Personal Information Secure. Your instructor will be choosing the discussion question and posting it as the first post in the main discussion forum. Discussion: Applying the Categorical Imperative. Philosophia (October 1975) 5(4): 395-416. Accessibility Statement, DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln, Faculty Publications - Department of Philosophy. You can test out of the Kant’s text and the textbook discuss two “formulations” or ways of expressing Kant’s Categorical Imperative, the “Formula of Universal Law” and the “Formula of Humanity.” These two principles go together, for the full context of the categorical imperative. An introduction to ethics and moral reasoning (3rd ed.). The wife is in fact there, and the manager of the shelter knows this. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. just create an account. without resorting to consequentialism, etc.)? This imperative is categorical. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. ” In our example, it is clear that by false promises I use the other as a means. Used by permission. Founder member of the International Society for Philosophers (ISFP) Your instructor will be choosing the discussion question and posting it as the first post in the main discussion forum. To most recent commentators, and to many earlier ones, it has seemed quite clear that the Categorical Imperative cannot be used to solve ethical problems. ( Log Out /  This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. ( Log Out /  And a recent commentator, T. C. Williams, remarks: The traditional…view of…the categorical imperative…as offering a precise standard or criterion against which the moral value of proposed actions might be tested…is unrewarding, for the strain in Kant’s thought which is emphasized by these writers and taken as representative of his basic position leads to a number of bizarre conclusions…which, perforce, have been universally rejected by commentators. A moral categorical imperative is one that provides a rule which applies to determining right or wrong. If we apply Kant's categorical imperative, would it be wrong for the manager to lie and say that the wife is somewhere else? Consider whether your peers have provided different analyses and/or responses than you did (or would, if it’s a different topic). ( Log Out /  Kant was a supporter of the death penalty. FAQ | Change ). Get access risk-free for 30 days, The approach to finding a categorical imperative is to take the action in question and ask whether the action can be universalized. | {{course.flashcardSetCount}} When Truman dropped the bomb on Hiroshima, his intention was not “to murder many humans” but to send a strong message.